I must think too much, but this thought struck me: Imagine stepping out of a time machine as a Pilgrim from the 1620s and landing smack in the middle of a modern Thanksgiving celebration. The sights, sounds, and tastes would be an overwhelming mix of the familiar and the utterly alien.
As I pondered this scenario, I couldn’t help but imagine how such a time traveler might experience our holiday. Let’s dive into what Thanksgiving might look like to someone journeying across centuries, from the first harvest feast to the 21st century.
The Feast
To a 17th-century traveler, the modern Thanksgiving table would be an astonishing spectacle of abundance. Golden-brown turkeys glisten under the soft glow of electric lights, surrounded by mountains of mashed potatoes, buttery rolls, and pies with flavors they couldn’t dream of—pecan?
Pumpkin with whipped cream? The sheer variety and abundance would feel miraculous, but perhaps also a bit unsettling.
Accustomed to meals of game meat, fish, and seasonal vegetables grown with painstaking effort, they might marvel at the efficiency of our food systems—but wonder at the cost. “Where did all this food come from?” they’d ask.
Explaining the concepts of industrial farming, refrigeration, and grocery stores might sound like a fairy tale. And canned cranberry sauce? It could be mistaken for some bizarre alchemical concoction or an overly sweet form of medicine.
The Magic of Modern Kitchens
The kitchen itself would leave them in speechless awe. To a Pilgrim, cooking was a grueling ritual involving firewood, cast-iron pots, and hours of labor.
The sight of a microwave reheating a slice of pie in mere seconds or an oven dutifully roasting a turkey at a precise, steady temperature would feel like sorcery.
Even a simple electric mixer would seem like a miracle tool, churning out mashed potatoes without breaking a sweat.
Convenience foods—pre-made pie crusts, boxed stuffing, or instant gravy—might leave them puzzled. “Why don’t you make it yourselves?” they might ask, baffled by the absence of a mortar and pestle or a garden close by.
It might lead them to wonder if, in simplifying our lives, we’ve lost a bit of the soul behind the meal. But even they would probably marvel at how much more time we have to enjoy the feast itself.
The Guests
Thanksgiving in 1621 was a significant cultural exchange between the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag people. But the diversity they’d witness in a modern dining room would take that idea to a whole new level.
They’d see families composed of people from all corners of the globe, bringing their own traditions, foods, and flavors to the table. There might be tamales alongside turkey, samosas beside stuffing, or kimchi paired with cranberry sauce.
The casual ease with which we navigate these multicultural celebrations might astound them. To a Pilgrim, deeply tied to their community and faith, such gatherings might seem both inspiring and confusing. And then there’s the conversation.
Talk of world events, faraway family members seen only via video calls, and the latest Netflix shows would feel dizzying. “How do you know so much about people and places so far away?” they might ask, struggling to grasp the concept of smartphones, social media, or the internet.
The Entertainment
Thanksgiving for the Pilgrims was a reflective, solemn occasion rooted in gratitude and prayer. Fast-forward to today, and they’d find a day filled with laughter, noise, and spectacle. Televisions would blare with football games—“Why are they wearing armor and chasing a ball?”—and the Macy’s
Thanksgiving Day Parade would likely seem like an outright carnival. Giant balloons of characters like Snoopy and Pikachu might look more like fantastical beasts than family entertainment.
Even the ways we give thanks have evolved. Grace before a meal might still resonate with them, but the jovial banter, board games, or kids glued to screens might leave them scratching their heads. And let’s not forget the wild clash of traditions they’d encounter the next day.
Black Friday Frenzy
If our time-traveling Pilgrim stuck around for the post-Thanksgiving shopping madness, they’d likely be horrified—or utterly perplexed.
The idea of gratitude and reflection giving way to a night of elbowing strangers for discounted TVs would feel antithetical to the values they held dear.
“Didn’t you just give thanks for what you have?” they might ask, unable to comprehend the stark contrast between the day of thanks and the day of consumerism.
Timeless Gratitude
Despite the overwhelming differences, one thing would likely feel comfortingly familiar: the spirit of gratitude. Even with our modern distractions, the essence of Thanksgiving—the joy of gathering with loved ones, reflecting on blessings, and sharing a meal—would strike a universal chord.
The sight of families bowing their heads in thanks, holding hands across a table, or sharing heartfelt toasts might reassure them. They’d recognize the warmth and humanity of the occasion, even amidst the strangeness of our modern rituals.
A Feast That Transcends Time
To a 17th-century Pilgrim, modern Thanksgiving would feel like stepping into a dreamscape of wonders. The abundance of food, the diversity of traditions, and the marvels of technology would astonish them.
But at its heart, they’d see the same spirit of connection, gratitude, and hope that shaped their own first Thanksgiving.
Maybe that’s what makes Thanksgiving so special—it’s a holiday that grows and changes with the times, yet never loses sight of its core purpose. Whether it’s venison and corn or turkey and pumpkin pie, it’s always been about the same thing: coming together, giving thanks, and cherishing the people around us. And that’s something even centuries of change can’t alter.
May you all have a wonderful Thanksgiving!
Comments